The Trouble With Rubrics

I used to be a practioner of Standards Based Grading (SBG). It was a step away from traditional grades and an important move as it helped signal to me the meaninglessness of traditional grading systems. In the midst of this, one of my colleagues would often talk about “Heberts effrots to rubricize the world.” At the time, I took it as a badge of honor: “That’s right. Everything in my course exists on a rubric. Students know exactly where they stand in each of the areas I deem important.”

Over time, however, I came to realize two things:

1. Standards Based Grading was still an attempt to quantify student learning. At the end of the day, I’m unconvinced that something as complicated as “learning” can be quantified. If it can be done, I’m pretty sure it’s not something that can be easily done, and I need someone to teach me this advanced skill.

2. That final phrase of my “badge of honor” statement above really began to bother me: “…the areas I deem important.” To be sure, I’m the expert in my classroom, but when we’re talking about textual interpretation why should we only focus on what the teacher deems important? Shouldn’t we consider what the students deem important?

These two insights caused the demise of rubrics in my classroom. First, I was still finding it difficult to assign some kind of point value to something like “Creativity.” How do I measure that? Once measured, how do I determine how that measurement should fit into the student’s overall grade for the assignment? For the grading period? For the year?

Second, I really want my classroom to be open to new possibilities. This is where rubrics really let me down. If all that matters on a given assignment are the things that I deem important, then I’m squashing the creativity and intellectual firepower of my students. I’m not giving them the option to color outside the lines. I hate that!

When we give a student a rubric, what we are saying is: “These are the things that matter. Only pay attention to them. Please and thank you.”

How awful is that?

That’s certainly not how I want to be treated! I want my independent thoughts to be valued. I want others to see what I think is important. Surely, my students feel the same way.

Rubrics work like a box. The things that go inside the box are valuable; the things that don’t are not. If we want to inspire creativity and outside-the-box thinking, then we shouldn’t trap students by putting them inside the box that they are supposed to get out of!

Rather than providing rubrics for the class or for individual assignments, I now give students prompts for assignments and then make comments on their work to let them know what I felt was effective and what wasn’t. I want students to enter into a conversation with me about this. Why did I think it was effective? Why not? Why did you, student, think it would be effective?

If we’re going to encourage students to be independent thinkers, then we need to encourage them to think independently and this includes allowing them to explore what they think is valuable.

Gaming Grades and Grading Games

As a teacher, I’ve often been frustrated with the issue of grades and grading. Here are a couple of observations and a couple of ideas for solutions:

1. Gaming Grades
Students often seem far more interested in playing what many teachers call “The Grade Game.” Rather than being interested in learning, students seem only interested in how they can get a better grade. This is most observable in those students deemed “grade grubbers”—e.g., the student who makes a 99 on a quiz and wants to quibble about that 1 point. Here are some questions that are frequently asked by the grade gamers:

  • What do I need to do to raise my grade?
  • Is there any extra credit I can do? (Typically asked at the end of a grading period.)
  • Is this for a grade?
  • How will this affect my grade?

You get the idea…

2. Grading Games
Grading games is sort of the reverse. This is where I, as a teacher, experience the agony of having to put grades on items that I don’t really want to put grades on. When a student turns in an essay or a piece of art or a short story, I might go through various hoops to try and figure out how I assess this thing.

You might be inclined to say that a rubric helps, but in my experience that only multiplies the problem. If the rubric has six categories on it, now I’ve got to find a way to put SIX different grades on this thing and then do some mathematical wizardry to produce a SINGLE grade for the gradebook. (At least Standards-Based Grading solves the second problem by allowing me to dispense with this single grade business.)

With or without a rubric, if you give a dozen teachers the same exact submission to grade, it’s very likely that you’re going to get a dozen different outcomes. Let’s not kid ourselves into believing that grades are standardized and that an A to you is the same as an A to me.

How do we solve these problems?

First, we have to recognize that excellent and inspiring teaching which is student-centered and empowering (e.g., Rhizomatic Learning) tends to help alleviate the Grading Game. Not completely, however. These students have grown up in performance-centered cultures and they are addicted to these grades.

Second, we need to seriously consider getting rid of grades or finding some alternative. Currently, I’m most interested in Mark Barnes’s narrative feedback system (SE2R) and hope to find a way to implement it in my classroom this Fall.

parenting in the present

I just spent five days in Vermont with the wife and the kiddo. I’m extremely thankful to get this week in Vermont each summer—a gift from a colleague and mentor—because it offers me an opportunity to completely disrupt my schedule and practice what I call: “Parenting in the Present.” (Alternatively, my wife calls this “Living in a House of Yes.”)

For me, “Parenting in the Present” means making a serious (and often painstaking) effort to forget about my wants and desires and to just be with my son, Gus. This means saying “yes” to what he wants to do.

“Dad, will you come outside with me and play ‘Pretend Baseball’?”

“Yes.”

“Dad, can we make a fire inside the fireplace and roast marshmallows?”

“Yes.”

The more I say “yes” to the things that he wants to do, the more it feels like he says “yes” to the things that I want to do. The key is to simply be in the moment with him. Whatever is going on, let’s do it. No time like the present. Mindfulness in action, really.

Of course, it takes me sometime to get into this mindfulness parenting mode. When we initially arrived, Gus asked if we could go immediately to the private beach where the canoes and kayaks are to be found. Knowing that I prefer to parent in the present, I said: “Sure!” We went down to the beach and played with the kayaks and splashed around in the water a bit. After about 45 minutes, however, I was tired of this and ready for dinner as it was getting late. I also knew that if we didn’t get to the house to make dinner, we’d disrupt his sleeping schedule and I may lose my opportunity to play games (e.g., Hive) with my wife. Gus agreeably got out of the water but was not all interested in heading up the stairs and toward the house. This led to quite a scene on the beach and me feeling like a terrible padre.

Of course, I know that if I’d just played another 10 minutes or so, Gus would’ve realized he was ready for dinner and he would’ve agreeably marched up the steps. In order for me to do that though, I’ve got to get rid of my own desires and be willing to just be in the moment.

This moment is the only one that I have, so why waste it pining for another?

What makes you think Paul is writing to you?

google-plus-banner

I’ve spent several hours tonight reading posts about Christianity on a variety of Google+ Communities. One question keeps springing to mind:

“What makes you think Paul is writing to you?”

It is very tempting to pick up the Bible, especially the letters of Paul, and assume that Paul is writing to us. When he uses second person pronouns, we get excited because he’s talking to us. We feel the same way when he uses first person pronouns, as if we are part of Paul’s club.

Here’s the thing:
When reading the Bible and arguing for some sort of “authorial intent” or “original meaning,” we should pay attention to context. Paul’s letters are occasional; they are written to a certain group of people at a certain place and time. No one living is part of that group. Therefore, we need to be careful about universalizing what Paul says. Simply because Paul says something about “you” or “we” doesn’t mean that he is referring to a 21st century Christian.

To be sure, much of what Paul writes is applicable to a modern Christian. I’m not saying none of it is about us. BUT, if we’re going to argue that it is indeed about us, then we need to be prepared to answer this question:

“What makes you think Paul is writing to you?”

Raised on the Last Day: a short argument against the idea that we go to Heaven when we die

Ladder of Divine Ascent (12th century)

In certain settings, I’ve been a bit notorious for arguing that Heaven isn’t a place populated by the souls of the righteous dead. This, of course, is the classic picture which has been handed down to us for roughly a millennium or more and has been most prevalent since the days of Dante. A full explanation of why I have difficulty buying into this picture would take a long time to explain, but this morning I was reminded of it as I read John 6.

To set the stage, John 6 contains the “Feeding of the Five Thousand,” followed by Jesus walking on water, and then the famous “Bread of Life” discourse which is found only in John. During this last section, Jesus repeatedly describes himself as the bread descending from Heaven, given by the Father, for the purpose of bringing eternal life to those who are willing to eat his flesh and drink his blood. (No wonder early Christians were considered cannibals by outsiders!)

The picture that Jesus presents doesn’t sound like we are living souls, as per Greek dualism, but that we are human beings who will die and will await our resurrection on the last day. Based on other New Testament texts, this resurrection is a whole body experience: We’ll be given a new, incorruptible body that will not perish, just like Jesus’s resurrection body as he is the firstborn of that resurrection.

So, what do you think? Do we possess eternal souls that wait in Heaven for the resurrection, perhaps looking down upon the living? Or are we fundamentally flesh, bodies lying dormant, waiting for the resurrection?

“Blood from Turnips” OR “A Thought on John 1.29”

Image

Recently, I acquired a copy of the UBS Greek New Testament Reader’s Edition with Textual Notes. (I hope to review it at some point, but with respect to that I’ll just say that I’m enjoying it!) I decided to start my adventures with it by reading the Gospel of John.

As I read the first chapter, something struck me that I know I’ve seen/read before, but hadn’t really thought about. John 1.29 goes like this (my translation):

On the next day, [John] saw Jesus coming to him and said, “Look! The lamb of God, the one taking the sin of the world!”

This, of course, is an interesting announcement. John has pointed out Jesus and designated him as the “lamb of God.” Then, John tells us that Jesus is taking away “the sin of the world.” I have two thoughts about this latter statement. [A quick caveat: As I do this, I’m simply interpreting on-the-go, trying to read John in an insular fashion without respect for other texts. I want to read John on his own terms. Consequently, this may not be the “best” or “most Biblical” interpretation.]

First, it is interesting to me that the participle airōn (above translated “taking”) is a present participle. As such, it maintains the tense of the verb of the sentence, ide (“Look!). Jesus is presently taking away the sin of the world. This is not something that happens only at the crucifixion and resurrection. Instead, Jesus’s presence in the world, his very existence, inaugurates the removal of sin.

Second, it is interesting to note that John does not say “sins of the world” are being taken away, but rather “sin” in the singular: hamartian. We often tend to think in more individualistic terms: I have done X, Y, and even Z; therefore, I have committed sins and I require a savior to purge me of those sins. There is nothing particularly wrong with this view, but John seems to see the situation from a different angle. It is not our individual sins that need purging, but rather this sort of corporate sin in which the whole of humanity may have taken part. Taking the Hebrew Bible as the relevant background for the Gospel of John, we might assume that this corporate sin can be summed up in the idea of prideful disobedience or rebellion as represented in various stories in Genesis (e.g., the disobedience of Adam and Eve in eating the fruit, the pride exhibited by Cain in his slaying Abel, the arrogance of the people in Babel who decided to build their tower to touch the heavens, etc.)

Bringing these ideas together, here’s what I come up with —

In John 1, we learn that Jesus is God and that he takes an extraordinary step in becoming human. His purpose, the mission which begins as soon as he comes into the world, is to take away human disobedience and rebellion, both of which have their roots in one common sin: pride or arrogance. (I can’t help but think of C.S. Lewis’s chapter called “The Great Sin” in Mere Christianity.) This mission is not something that is accomplished only by his death and resurrection (as perhaps certain proponents of substitutionary atonement would argue), but happens in the presence of Jesus.

This all leads me to one final question:
If Jesus is taking away the sin of the world, and if Jesus is successful, then how can a human stand condemned?

Race, Class, and Gender in American History

Carson posted an interesting article the other day about a study that recommends that Texas A&M and the University of Texas pay less attention to the themes of race, class, and gender in their American history curricula. If you want to read me gagging legibly, check out my lengthy comment to his article.

The Faceless God and the Face of God

Elijah & the LORD sacrifice a bull in 1 Kings 18 (http://yearinthebible.files.wordpress.com/2012/11/1-kings-18-sacrifice.jpg)

Today’s lectionary includes 1 Kings 18:20–21, (22–29), 30–39. In this passage, Elijah proposes a sort of contest between him and the worshippers of Baal. Each group sacrifices a bull, but instead of lighting the fire themselves, they will call upon their god to see whose will actually respond. The Baal worshippers call upon him for hours, but to no avail. Afterward, Elijah calls upon the LORD who rains down fire from heaven to consume the sacrifice. It’s exciting stuff!

As I read this this morning, I was struck by conversations that I’ve had with many atheists over the years. When asked what it would take for them to believe, they often reply: “God would have to show himself to me.” Being a Christian, I sometimes appeal to the wonders of the universe (from distant galaxies to the Grand Canyon to the miracle that is water), but usually to no avail. These folks are interested in a physical manifestation of God; they want a bearded man to appear out of nowhere. I don’t blame them. This whole thing might be a lot easier if God would just do that.

This story from 1 Kings both reinforces and works against that need of ours to see the divine.

On the one hand, here is one of the LORD’s prophets calling upon him to do something specific: “God, burn this stuff up to prove to these guys that you are for real.” The subsequent fireworks show that the LORD means business, Elijah is right, and these Baal worshippers need to get with the program.

On the other hand, there is no physical manifestation, no bearded man appearing out of nowhere. God remains formless; God remains faceless. The decalogue commands Jews to “make no graven image” of the LORD, but it should be noted that there is no image to engrave. Even when Moses sees God in Exodus 33, he does not see his face, but only his back.

How then do we relate to someone like this? How do we come to understand that which we cannot put a face to? There are two possible answers:

  1. We can attempt to transcend our attachment to things. We must recognize that God is not a thing to be understood. Consequently, let’s adjust our understanding and our verbiage so that we don’t think of him in this way.
  2. We give God a face.

In some ways, both answers are necessary. We really should adjust our picture of things to de-objectify God. The LORD is not a thing in the same way that my body is a thing. At the same time, the second answer, to give God a face, is about as Christian as it gets. Jesus is God embodied, incarnate, fleshed out.

Jesus is the face of the faceless God.

Hallowing Time

In his prologue to The Sabbath, A.J. Heschel writes: “We must not forget that it is not a thing that lends significance to a moment; it is the moment that lends significance to things.” Heschel aims to reclaim the sanctity of time from a world obsessed with what he calls “thinginess” or “thinghood,” an obsession with space and the things that occupy it to the detriment of time which, for Heschel, is at least of equal importance.

Heschel is right. The various objects that occupy our space really only acquire significance when they are attached to important moments: a loop of gold is of great significance because my wife placed it on my finger at our wedding; a pen becomes worthy of a museum exhibit because it was used to sign the Civil Rights Act of 1964; a 6-4-3 double play is significant not because it happened in a practice, but because it ended a World Series. This is no less true of religious events: a humble wafer or a simple candle are imbued with importance at the Eucharist or during the Paschal season. Apart from these moments, they are mere objects, or in the parlance of Heschel, things.

Recently, I’ve read not only The Sabbath, but also All Things Shining. In both, a premium is placed on time and recognition of time as something important, as worthy of our notice. For Heschel, time is not the enemy, but the sacred temple that God has constructed for humans. For Hubert Dreyfus and Sean Dorrance Kelly, time as event or moment plays a role in the communal sort of mood that we should learn to recognize and give in to. 

In either case, there is a recognition that the soulless drudgery of the day-to-day is of little importance if not accompanied by a sort of hallowing of time: be it a blessing of the Sabbath or a recognition of the mood.

I’m struck by this. Question: What do a dead Jewish theologian and a pair of secular philosophers have in common? Answer: A call to pay attention to the passage of time, to mark the moment.

Each semester, my students read Jonathan Sarna’s A Time to Every Purpose, in which Prof. Sarna also marks out the importance of time, specifically for the modern, reformed Jew.

Is this conversation happening amongst Christians? Is my own tradition interested in this issue of hallowing time?

I’ve seen some discussions of sabbath from Christians, most of whom seem to think that Sunday is the “Christian Sabbath” — it’s not, by the way, as Sabbath observance is one of several Biblical commandments that early Christians decided to ignore. Moreover, these discussions seem to center on the notion of withdrawal from the world.

Heschel views the Sabbath not as withdrawal from the world, but engagement in it, engagement in the one thing that God actually blesses and consecrates in the midst of the creation story of Genesis 1: the seventh day. Likewise, Jesus sees the Sabbath not as a moment to withdraw from the world, but as a moment to continue engaging with it, doing what the Father has appointed him to do.

This is a bit meandering because, to be perfectly honest, I’m not really sure what my point is. I do think that an epiphany is coming. Hopefully, I’ll be open enough to recognize the mood when it arrives…

Suffering, Endurance, Character, Hope

This year’s lectionary for Trinity Sunday includes Romans 5.1–5:

1 Therefore, since we have been justified by faith, we have peace with God through our Lord Jesus Christ. 2 Through him we have also obtained access by faith into this grace in which we stand, and we rejoice in hope of the glory of God. 3 Not only that, but we rejoice in our sufferings, knowing that suffering produces endurance, 4 and endurance produces character, and character produces hope, 5 and hope does not put us to shame, because God’s love has been poured into our hearts through the Holy Spirit who has been given to us. (ESV)

This morning, I was discussing this particular passage with some friends, when I began to hit upon an interesting way to read this that had never really occurred to me before. I’m not saying it’s new, just new to me.

Beginning in v. 3 there is an interesting chain that Paul sets up:

suffering → endurance → character → hope

First, before moving any further, I need to challenge this translation, specifically the word “character” for the Greek dokimē. While “character” is an acceptable gloss, it doesn’t necessarily get across the meaning of the Greek term which is more akin to: “proven by testing or trial.” This isn’t simply character, but some kind of fortitude or strength that has been proven by the vigorous testing of the sufferings mentioned earlier in v. 3. So, here’s our new little chain:

suffering → endurance → proven/tried/tested → hope

How exactly does this work? How do we get from one suffering to hope along this chain? What are the steps in between? It may seem odd to us to think that in the midst of suffering, in the midst of difficulty, that is when we will begin to produce hope. Isn’t that when all of this should break down? Shouldn’t we lose hope in the midst of trial? To answer this, we need to move back and make sure that we understand where we are now.

In Romans 4, Paul develops Abraham as our human hero because he has faith in God and this faith is reckoned to him as righteousness. Faith justifies. Paul says that we have peace with God because of this justification brought by faith. Our faith allows us to have peace with God even in the midst of suffering. Without that faith, without that trust, we don’t have peace, but we live in desperation as the universe throws its punches.

This faith then is a really important thing. What we have faith in is the notion that God is in control, that he is active and alive in our world. He is not the deistic being who wound up the world, set it spinning, and then turned his back. No. He’s the Abrahamic Monotheos who enters into the world, intervening, working, creating, sustaining, re-creating. Be he Yahweh, Abba, or Allah: this God is here, real, and active.

Through Jesus, we have access to this hope: hope that God will reveal his glory and that we will partake of it (v. 2), heirs to the Kingdom, princes and princesses of the new world order that is actively overthrowing the current “bogus world system” (in the parlance of Jack Wisdom).

Are you one of these heirs? Are you a prince or princess? Here’s how you’ll know. You’ll rejoice in suffering and learn to endure. By enduring and rejoicing in the midst of your suffering, you’ll be proven, tested, and tried: you’ll know that this thing is genuine and your hope will be reinforced.

Suffering leads to hope because it is in suffering that we come to know who we truly are: heirs to the glory of God, heirs to the Kingdom. How do you know the Spirit dwells with you and in you? Because you have been proven acceptable by your endurance in the face of trial, by the steadfastness of your hope and of your faith even when things are bleak.